Taste the moment
Welcome to Little Italy Pizzeria
Little Italy Pizzeria is a beloved gem in the heart of Auburn, GA, celebrated for its authentic Italian-American cuisine. This cozy spot offers a delightful array of pizzas, pasta, calzones, and sandwiches, all crafted with fresh ingredients and generous portions. Guests rave about the made-to-order pizza by the slice, which allows for customization and delivers deliciousness with every bite. The casual atmosphere is perfect for families and friends, and the friendly staff ensures a welcoming experience. Whether you're craving a late-night slice or a hearty meal, Little Italy Pizzeria promises a satisfying dining adventure that keeps patrons coming back for more.
Inspired Moments
Enjoy a mix of flavors and experiences
Bud Light (Single)
Pesto Pizza
#4 Eggplant Parmesan
#3 Sausage Parmesan
Story & Atmosphere
Little Italy Pizzeria
Welcome to Little Italy Pizzeria, your go-to destination for authentic Italian-American comfort food nestled in the heart of Auburn, Alabama. Located at 129 E Magnolia Ave, this charming establishment is not just a pizzeria; it’s a culinary haven for pizza lovers and families alike. With a reputation for serving up hot, fresh pizzas and a delightful array of other Italian staples, Little Italy Pizzeria is the perfect spot to satisfy your late-night cravings or enjoy a wholesome family dinner.
Step inside, and you’ll immediately feel the warm, welcoming atmosphere that sets the stage for a perfect dining experience. The decor embodies a casual vibe that invites patrons to relax and enjoy their meal at leisure, making it a favorite local haunt. It's this inviting ambiance combined with the friendly, patient staff that keeps customers coming back for more, as highlighted in the rave reviews from satisfied guests.
One of the standout features of Little Italy Pizzeria is their unique approach to pizza by the slice. Customers have praised this method as the ideal way to enjoy freshly cooked pizza tailored to your liking, with toppings added right before baking. As Abigail F. notes, the efficiency of ordering a slice that's cooked just for you is a refreshing change from the typical selection of pre-made pies.
The culinary offerings go beyond pizza; the menu is filled with hearty pasta dishes, calzones, and sandwiches, all crafted with generous portions and tantalizing flavors. Diners rave about the crispy crusts, cheesy toppings, and flavorful sauces that make each bite a celebration of Italian cuisine. CJ encapsulates this sentiment, emphasizing both the delicious food and exceptional service that contribute to the overall experience.
Despite its humble appearance, with some even calling it a 'dive,' Little Italy Pizzeria promises an unforgettable experience. Mary Hansel captures this perfectly by noting that it’s the kind of spot where you can unwind, enjoy your food, and not feel pressured to leave. Whether you're sharing a pie after a late night out or gathering with family for a cozy meal, the atmosphere is just right for any occasion.
As confirmed by Russ Coker, many believe that Little Italy Pizzeria offers the best pizza in Auburn. Whether you’re looking for a quick slice on the go or a more leisurely meal, you'll find a satisfying option to suit your craving. The convenient location enhances its appeal, making it an easy choice for anyone in the area.
So, the next time you find yourself in Auburn, seek out Little Italy Pizzeria. With its generous portions, freshly made dishes, and inviting atmosphere, it's a place where good food and great memories come together. Call ahead at (334) 821-6161 if you're on the go, or drop by to experience the best of Italian-American cuisine.
What Guests Say
Guestbook
“ Pizza is always hot and made for you!! Pizza by the slice is the way to go, it was delicious!! They add toppings to your slice then cook it. I actually prefer this rather than having like 10 pizzas made that you have to choose from like some places. The staff is super friendly and they are also patient when we had never ordered there before. We went on a Friday night at 10pm in April and it was busy! There are tables of all sizes inside to sit at. They serve Pepsi products. They do give you a water cup if desired. We ordered a slice of pep/sausage and it was so so good!! I also got ranch to dip it and it tasted great and was 55 cents. The individual slices are like 12inches long and 5 inches wide. The crust was fluffy and so delicious, not burnt either. We also got an eggplant 6inch sandwich. I will say that I had to buy the 55cent marinara to put on the sandwich because it just needed something. The eggplant was a bit chewy. But the marinara was delicious, probably homemade. They have an ordering system that just works, where you get a number at the top of your reciept. They call your number on a microphone and you have to show a receipt at the pickup section. ”
“ Little Italy Pizzeria Little Italy Pizzeria is a casual, family-friendly spot known for its classic Italian-American fare. The pizzeria offers a wide range of pizzas, pasta dishes, calzones, and sandwiches, often praised for generous portions and fresh ingredients. Guests appreciate the crispy, cheesy pizzas and flavorful sauces. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, making it ideal for family dinners or casual gatherings with friends. Service is generally friendly, though some reviews note that wait times can be longer during busy hours. Overall, it’s recommended for those craving hearty, traditional Italian comfort food at reasonable prices. ”
“ The pizza was delicious! I enjoyed the food and the service. Conveniently located and easy to walk to! ”
“ Let's be honest, this place is a dive, but in the way you want dives to be. Pizza is yummy and fresh, beer is cheap and plentiful, and you can grab a table and hang out all night with no pressure. ”
“ Honestly this is the best pizza in Auburn. Great little hole in the wall spot, really straightforward and a great piece to get a slice. Don’t going thinking you’re gunna have a Michelin star experience, but if you want a good late night slice of pie, this is the spot. Will always recommend this spot. ”